Newest American Cheese

Out of Stock
Your Price: $5.80
Red Apple smoked cheese are made with milk sourced from some of the oldest dairy farms in Chippewa County, Wisconsin. Prior to smoking, the cheeses are extra-aged to enhance taste. The cheese masters then slowly, meticulously, naturally... read more
In Stock
Your Price: $10.67
Goat Lady Dairy named their fresh goat's milk cheese after the monumental landscape of the Smoky Mountains that surrounds the creamery. Smokey Mt. Rounds are hand formed delightful balls that are dried and lightly smoked over applewood,... read more
In Stock
Your Price: $9.71
Goat Lady Dairy produces this small goat-cow-brie. The interior has a chalky dense core surrounded by a layer that oozes, which is surrounded by a bloomy white rind. Snow Camp Cheese has light clean flavors of a young goat cheese with notes of... read more
In Stock
Your Price: $8.68
This Truffle Cheddar has a heady, earthy aroma from both fresh truffles and truffle oil that are infused into this mild cheese. Sweet and buttery flavors provide the anchor for the musky, earthy, sensual aromas of truffle that pervade this... read more
Out of Stock
From: $32.44
Dancing Fern Cheese is named for the native ferns that sway and nod at the breezy mouth of a cave in Coppinger Cove where the Sequatchie creamery is located. This gourmet cheese is inspired by the famous raw milk Reblochon cheese of the Savoie... read more
In Stock
Was $7.76 Now: $7.37
This semi-soft, creamy goat milk jack cheese has a mild, milky flavor that is complimented by a proprietary blend of zesty peppers. It has a rich, buttery mouth feel that becomes increasingly creamy with age. LaClare Family Creamery is a true... read more
In Stock
Your Price: $5.99
Wisconsin's Roth cheese makes the Van Gogh Gouda from full cream and pasteurized cow's milk. The cheese is aged for 6-8 months, creating a beautiful creamy texture with a touch of caramel. This cheese pairs well with stone fruits, nuts and your... read more
Out of Stock
From: $28.98
Nickajack is a raw cow's milk cheese with a meaty buttery paste. It is washed in Michigan-made JK Scrumpy’s hard cider, turning the rind a golden-tan to orange-red color. The aroma of this gourmet cheese, after 60 days of aging, is approachable... read more
In Stock
Your Price: $9.42
The Rattlesnake is a true flavor experience — spicy, sweet, tropical, and HOT. This smooth, creamy medium aged Cheddar is infused with premium gold tequila and Habanero peppers. The warmth and sweetness of the tequila open your palate to the... read more
Out of Stock
Your Price: $8.51
Purple Moon Cheddar Cheese is truly a one-of-a-kind cheese. It is wine and cheese in one, but please serve it with some wine to enjoy it even more. This unique cheese is created by soaking Fascalini's traditional cheddar in locally produced... read more