Newest American Cheese

In Stock
From: $32.28
Nickajack is a raw cow's milk cheese with a meaty buttery paste. It is washed in Michigan-made JK Scrumpy’s hard cider, turning the rind a golden-tan to orange-red color. The aroma of this gourmet cheese, after 60 days of aging, is approachable... read more
Out of Stock
Your Price: $9.97
The Rattlesnake is a true flavor experience — spicy, sweet, tropical, and HOT. This smooth, creamy medium aged Cheddar is infused with premium gold tequila and Habanero peppers. The warmth and sweetness of the tequila open your palate to the... read more
Out of Stock
Your Price: $8.41
Purple Moon Cheddar Cheese is truly a one-of-a-kind cheese. It is wine and cheese in one, but please serve it with some wine to enjoy it even more. This unique cheese is created by soaking Fascalini's traditional cheddar in locally produced... read more
In Stock
From: $21.24
Sequatchie Cove Creamery's Cumberland Cheese is a raw cow's milk cheese with a natural rind and a smooth semi-firm texture. This flavorful Tomme-style has an earthy aroma of dried leaves and a fruity, tangy rich buttermilk flavor. The milk... read more
In Stock
From: $27.32
When you remember the French cheese Morbier, you may recognize the Coppinger cheese, made by Sequatchie Cove Creamery. Nathan and Padgett Arnold are the owners of this small creamery that is 100 percent solar powered; they strive to be as... read more
In Stock
Your Price: $4.99
Vermont Creamery took their classic, mild fresh goat cheese and hand rolled in the familiar flavors of New York’s favorite breakfast food. This Everything Goat Cheese is coated with a mix of sesame seed, dried onion, dried garlic, spices, poppy... read more
In Stock
Your Price: $11.03
A flower shaped creamy cheese from Lena Illinois; Comeback Cow Cheese. This cute little cheese is mild, yet complex, rich and creamy with a soft white mold exterior, that is tinged orange with age. A velvety milk taste is underlined by sweet... read more
In Stock
Your Price: $11.03
Keep Dreaming is a complex and creamy cheese with tangy notes, and when maturing, it becomes more robust. It is made in Illinois with full-bodied cow's milk and creme fraiche. This combination creates a very deliciously soft cheese with a rich,... read more
In Stock
Your Price: $11.14
Karst is an original, American artisan cheese, which has been cave-aged to perfection in the cheese cellars at Jasper Hill in Vermont. This cheese is like a blend of Gruyere and Cheddar cheese with a natural rind.Made from pasteurized cow's... read more
In Stock
Was $6.52 Now: $5.87
This small jar is filled with the highest quality goat curd that is marinating in light garlic-infused extra virgin olive oil (EVOO) blend, mixed with Californian dill pollen - a delicious combination. Gerard and Susan Tuck are the creators of... read more