Vegetarian Rennet Cheese

Out of Stock
From: $22.98
Kerrygold knows a thing or two about making Irish cheese. This aged cheddar infused with whiskey is proof of that. The Irish love whiskey - this time they poured some into the cheese.  The flavor is rich and creamy with the added Irish... read more
In Stock
Your Price: $6.98
Kerrygold's Aged Irish Cheddar is made with milk from cows that roam and graze in lush pastures of tender grass. From this idyllic environment and extraordinary diet come luscious milk so rich in beta-carotene, it can turn cheddar cheese into a... read more
Out of Stock
From: $20.98
Aged Red Leicester (officially called Leicestershire) is a cloth-bound cheese that is matured for 6 months, resulting in a hard, flaky, beautifully orange cheese with a slightly sweet, caramelized flavor. It's the only pasteurized Red Leicester... read more
In Stock
Your Price: $11.98
Aphrodite Traditional Barrel-Aged Feta selected by Will Studd is made in Greece from a combination of goat and ewe milk. Authentic handmade Greek barrel-ripened feta is rare, and it tastes different to modern feta matured in airtight tins. This... read more
In Stock
From: $8.98
Carr Valley makes a white cheddar that is smoked over applewood and hand rubbed with paprika. The Apple Smoked Cheddar has an deep orange/red appearance, an ivory-white interior and a supple, moist texture that is typical of Wisconsin Carr... read more
In Stock
Was $33.98 Now: $29.98
Cypress Grove is one of America's original goat cheese makers. The goats on the Cypress Grove farm in rural Humboldt County enjoy the lush pastures provided by the mild Northern California Pacific coastal climate which results in award-winning... read more
In Stock
Your Price: $6.98
We didn't think this delicious Pimento cheese from New Bridge could get any better, but this new recipe with the addition of bacon has changed our minds. A new twist on the perennial Southern classic, this Bacon Pimento Cheese will be a new... read more
In Stock
Your Price: $5.98
Balsamic BellaVitano is a twist on BellaVitano Gold: an award-winning firm cheese from Wisconsin, made in the style of Parmesan and inspired by other hard Italian cheeses. This version is soaked with aged Modena balsamic vinegar which gives the... read more
In Stock
On Sale From: $19.98
Barely Buzzed is an artisanal cheese hand-crafted by Tim Welsh and Pat Ford of the Beehive Cheese Company in Utah. Tim and Pat were brothers-in-law before leaving corporate jobs to team up and make cheese.  The base cheese is their... read more
In Stock
Your Price: $7.98
This authentic handmade feta is made using artisanal techniques that harken back to a long history of Greek feta. This feta is made of both goat and sheep milk, per Greek tradition, and is aged for 3 months in wooden barrels instead of more... read more